Ghana - Ghana’s finance minister Ken Ofori-Atta announced that the
government intends to introduce an electronic transaction levy (e-levy) in the
2022 budget. He said this was to “widen the tax net and rope in the informal
sector”.
The proposed levy, which will come into effect on 1 February 2022,
is a charge of 1.75% of the value of electronic transactions. It covers mobile
money payments, bank transfers, merchant payments, and inward remittances. The
originator of the transactions will bear the charge except for inward
remittances, which will be borne by the recipient. There is an exemption for
transactions up to GH¢100 (US$ 16) per day.
According to the Finance Minister, the total digital transactions
for 2020 were estimated to
be over GH¢500 billion (about US$81 billion) compared to GH¢78 billion
(US$12.5billion) in 2016. Huge growth in just five years.
While the justification for this new levy is to widen the tax net,
since the majority of the population makes a living in the informal sector, it seems a
convenient means to increase government revenue. Initial response to the
announcement of the levy has been one of displeasure and fears that it will
affect the country’s current digitisation agenda.
I do not expect these responses to lead to a reversal, as was
done recently with
the payment of benchmark values at ports. However, the government may revisit
the implementation and subsequent charges given the existing cost on mobile
money.
There are a number of reasons why the government is not likely to
backtrack. Ghanaians should brace themselves for this levy.
Why government may not backtrack
No viable alternatives: Though this e-levy may force some people
to resort to the use of cash, for the majority, there is no viable alternative.
At the moment, electronic payment, especially mobile money, is the most
efficient and cost effective means of transferring money since it is widely accessible in Ghana. Its wide use is because of its convenience, especially in rural areas. The only alternative is to use banks, which have
limited branches. And banks themselves are now digitising their services to
minimise the use of cash.
My research into
the use of financial technology in Ghana has shown that in the absence of
practical alternatives, mobile money is the only means for many people to
access financial services. The research also indicates that the cost associated
with mobile money is not an inhibitor. Thus, irrespective of the e-levy, people
will still use mobile money.
Easy means of generating revenue: Successive
governments have failed to find innovative solutions to expand the tax net to
include the informal sector, although this sector employs the majority of Ghanaians at about 85% of the urban economy. As many people,
including those in the informal sector, use mobile money, the government sees it
as an easy way of taxing the informal sector. Estimates show
that in 2020, the total volume of mobile money transactions was over US$99 billion
(GH¢561 billion) far surpassing cheque and cash transactions which stood at US$29 billion. Given the potential revenue the government can generate and as it
is unable to devise any innovative solution to tax the informal sector, mobile
money taxation appears to be the easy way out.
Digital payment institutionalisation: In recent times,
the government has embarked on digitalisation
projects to reduce the use of cash. Among these is the e-currency
(e-cedi) project, in which the Central Bank will issue its “own
version of mobile money”. The roll-out of the e-cedi may further limit the use
of cash, forcing people to use electronic payments, so people will have to pay
the e-levy.
The government is also moving to a digital only payment option for
its services, to curb corruption and revenue leaks. This means that without
digital payment, people may struggle to access certain services such as getting
a passport or driver’s licence, registering a company or clearing goods at the
port. It’s another reason people will have little choice but to pay the e-levy.
Digital payment normalisation: With emergence of COVID and imposition of
restriction on movement and the fact that mobile money, bank accounts and cards
have become more closely linked, many people resorted to digital transactions and payment for most of their day
to day economic activities. The government asserts that
the value of digital transactions rose by 120% between February 2020 and February
2021. In the previous year it rose 44%. The government is aware that most
people are now accustomed to online transactions. They are convenient and
people will find it difficult to revert to physical transactions.
Many people will not be in favour of the e-levy because of existing
charges on mobile money. There is also the risk that it could derail the growth
of the Ghanaian FinTech ecosystem by making Ghana unattractive for FinTech
startups. For instance, this e-levy will reduce the profit margins of FinTech
startups who may not wish to pass on the cost to consumers. In 2021, Zeepay, an indigenous Ghanaian FinTech
Firm alone attracted about US$7.6 million investment.
Given the direct and indirect benefits FinTech contributes to
economies, this e-levy will become an additional problem for already struggling
FinTech startups. It appears that the government is only thinking of short term
revenue gains. Thus, government should relook at the implementation and
strategically target the tax instead of the blanket e-levy on digital payment.
It should be guided by lessons from other countries like Uganda who
have also implemented mobile money tax.
By: Prof. PK Senyo
